Booklet That Upset Mrs. Cheney Is History

The Depart­ment of Edu­ca­tion destroyed 300,000 par­ent guides on “How to Help Your Child Learn His­to­ry” because Mrs. Cheney did­n’t like a ref­er­ence to one of her pet peeves.
Big Sis­ter, anyone?

Pub­lished on Fri­day, Octo­ber 8, 2004 by the Los Ange­les Times
Book­let That Upset Mrs. Cheney Is History
The Depart­ment of Edu­ca­tion destroys 300,000 par­ent guides to remove ref­er­ences to nation­al standards.
by Ricar­do Alon­so-Zal­divar and Jean Merl

WASHINGTON — The Edu­ca­tion Depart­ment this sum­mer destroyed more than 300,000 copies of a book­let designed for par­ents to help their chil­dren learn his­to­ry after the office of Vice Pres­i­dent Dick Cheney’s wife com­plained that it men­tioned the Nation­al Stan­dards for His­to­ry, which she has long opposed.

In June, dur­ing a rou­tine update, the Edu­ca­tion Depart­ment began dis­trib­ut­ing a new edi­tion of a 10-year-old how-to guide called “Help­ing Your Child Learn His­to­ry.” Aimed at par­ents of chil­dren from preschool through fifth grade, the 73-page book­let pre­sent­ed an assort­ment of advice, includ­ing tak­ing chil­dren to muse­ums and vis­it­ing his­tor­i­cal sites.

Extreme­ly trou­bling. That’s a pret­ty god-awful exam­ple of spend­ing the tax­pay­ers’ mon­ey and also a pret­ty god-awful exam­ple of inter­fer­ence — intel­lec­tu­al inter­fer­ence. If that’s not Big Broth­er or Big Sis­ter, I don’t know what is.

Retired UCLA pro­fes­sor Gary Nash, co-chair­man of the effort to devel­op the Nation­al Stan­dards for History
The book­let includ­ed sev­er­al brief ref­er­ences to the Nation­al Stan­dards for His­to­ry, which were devel­oped at UCLA in the mid-1990s with fed­er­al sup­port. Cre­at­ed by schol­ars and edu­ca­tors to help school offi­cials design bet­ter his­to­ry cours­es, they are vol­un­tary bench­marks, not manda­to­ry requirements.

At the time, Lynne Cheney, the wife of now-Vice Pres­i­dent Cheney, led a vocif­er­ous cam­paign com­plain­ing that the stan­dards were not pos­i­tive enough about Amer­i­ca’s achieve­ments and paid too lit­tle atten­tion to fig­ures such as Gen. Robert E. Lee, Paul Revere and Thomas Edison.

At one point in the ini­tial con­tro­ver­sy, Cheney denounced the stan­dards as “politi­cized history.”

In response to the crit­i­cism, the UCLA stan­dards were heav­i­ly revised, most crit­ics were mol­li­fied and the con­tro­ver­sy fad­ed — but not for Cheney and her staff.

“Help­ing Your Child Learn His­to­ry” is not unique. The Edu­ca­tion Depart­ment pro­duces a series of sim­i­lar book­lets on top­ics such as sci­ence, geog­ra­phy, read­ing and math. The book­lets are designed to encour­age par­ents to get involved in their chil­dren’s edu­ca­tion. Often, they con­tain pass­ing ref­er­ences to the kinds of cur­ricu­lum stan­dards that schol­ars and edu­ca­tors have devel­oped in recent years to improve school cours­es. More than 9 mil­lion copies of such book­lets have been distributed.

Sel­dom have the book­lets sparked con­tro­ver­sy. That changed this summer.

As the wife of the vice pres­i­dent, Cheney has no exec­u­tive posi­tion in the fed­er­al gov­ern­ment. But when her office spot­ted the ref­er­ences to the Nation­al Stan­dards for His­to­ry in the new edi­tion of the his­to­ry book­let, her staff com­mu­ni­cat­ed its dis­plea­sure to the Edu­ca­tion Department.

Sub­se­quent­ly, the depart­ment decid­ed it was nec­es­sary to kill the new edi­tion and reprint it with ref­er­ences to the stan­dards removed. Though about 61,000 copies of “Help­ing Your Child Learn His­to­ry” had been dis­trib­uted, the remain­ing 300,000-plus copies were destroyed. Asked about the deci­sion, one depart­ment offi­cial said they had been “recy­cled.”

The Times obtained a copy of the book­let as orig­i­nal­ly printed.

A new ver­sion of the book­let, the basis for the ver­sion that is being print­ed, is on the Edu­ca­tion Depart­men­t’s web­site. It has been edit­ed to remove ref­er­ences to the standards.

For exam­ple, a clause in the fore­word was removed that sug­gest­ed Pres­i­dent Bush sup­port­ed instruc­tion based on teach­ing stan­dards that had been devel­oped for var­i­ous aca­d­e­m­ic subjects.

Also miss­ing from the depart­men­t’s Inter­net ver­sion is a sug­ges­tion that par­ents ask whether their chil­dren’s cur­ricu­lum incor­po­rates the Nation­al Stan­dards for His­to­ry. An Inter­net address for the stan­dards in a list of more than a dozen web­sites for par­ents was also removed, as well as a foot­note else­where in the text that shows where to find more infor­ma­tion about the his­to­ry standards.

When The Times ini­tial­ly approached the Edu­ca­tion Depart­ment to inquire about the book­lets, the depart­ment issued a state­ment say­ing it had tak­en the unusu­al action because of “mis­takes, includ­ing typos and incom­plete information.”

Lat­er, Susan Aspey, the depart­men­t’s press sec­re­tary, admit­ted that typo­graph­i­cal errors were not the rea­son. Asked about the role of Cheney’s office, Aspey responded:

“The deci­sion was ours to stop dis­tri­b­u­tion and reprint. Both offices were on par­al­lel tracks and obvi­ous­ly nei­ther of us were pleased that the final doc­u­ment was not the accu­rate reflec­tion of pol­i­cy that was approved originally.”

A rep­re­sen­ta­tive for Cheney said her office did not order the destruc­tion of the book­lets. “Unequiv­o­cal­ly, [nei­ther] Mrs. Cheney nor her staff insist­ed on hav­ing the his­to­ry pub­li­ca­tion recalled,” said spokes­woman Maria Miller. “And that’s just the bot­tom line.”

How­ev­er, nei­ther depart­ment offi­cials nor Cheney’s office would dis­cuss the episode in detail. Both refused to allow inter­views with the staffers involved.

Indi­vid­u­als with knowl­edge of the events said com­plaints from Cheney’s office moved the Edu­ca­tion Depart­ment to act. The indi­vid­u­als spoke on con­di­tion of anonymity.

Retired UCLA pro­fes­sor Gary Nash, co-chair­man of the effort to devel­op the Nation­al Stan­dards for His­to­ry, said he found the deci­sion to destroy the book­lets after Cheney’s office com­plained “extreme­ly troubling.”

“That’s a pret­ty god-awful exam­ple of spend­ing the tax­pay­ers’ mon­ey and also a pret­ty god-awful exam­ple of inter­fer­ence — intel­lec­tu­al inter­fer­ence,” Nash said. “If that’s not Big Broth­er or Big Sis­ter, I don’t know what is.”

Accord­ing to Michelle M. Her­c­zog, a con­sul­tant in his­to­ry and social sci­ences for the Los Ange­les Coun­ty Office of Edu­ca­tion, the stan­dards have become a resource for many states in devel­op­ing cur­ricu­lum guide­lines. They are also used to devel­op textbooks.

“Why the U.S. Depart­ment of Edu­ca­tion would take that out of a fed­er­al doc­u­ment for par­ents is just beyond me,” said Her­c­zog, who was not involved in the devel­op­ment of the standards.

The answer is that, from their incep­tion, the Amer­i­can his­to­ry guide­lines have been caught in an ide­o­log­i­cal feud.

Cheney led the charge on the orig­i­nal UCLA draft. In a wide­ly read opin­ion piece pub­lished in 1994, she com­plained that “We are a bet­ter peo­ple than the Nation­al Stan­dards indi­cate, and our chil­dren deserve to know it.”

The stan­dards con­tained repeat­ed ref­er­ences to the Ku Klux Klan and to Sen. Joseph McCarthy, the anti-Com­mu­nist dem­a­gogue of the 1950s, she said. And she not­ed that Har­ri­et Tub­man, the escaped slave who helped run the Under­ground Rail­road, was men­tioned six times.

But Revere, Lee, the Wright broth­ers and oth­er promi­nent fig­ures went unmen­tioned, she said.

Such com­plaints led to revi­sion of the standards.

Recent­ly, when the depart­ment decid­ed to update “Help­ing Your Child Learn His­to­ry,” Cheney’s office became involved because of her long-stand­ing inter­est in Amer­i­can history.

Cheney is promi­nent­ly quot­ed in the book­let as a “not­ed author and wife of the vice pres­i­dent.” Two books on his­to­ry that she wrote for chil­dren are men­tioned in the booklet.

The acknowl­edg­ments also cred­it her office for help­ing with the guide, which cost $110,360 to print, Aspey said.

As head of the Nation­al Endow­ment for the Human­i­ties under Pres­i­dents Rea­gan and George H.W. Bush, Cheney approved some of the fund­ing for the Nation­al Stan­dards for His­to­ry project, but she also issued a blis­ter­ing cri­tique of social sci­ence edu­ca­tion, which is list­ed as a resource in the booklet.

The his­to­ry book­let was first pub­lished in 1993. Hav­ing made edu­ca­tion reform a cen­ter­piece of its domes­tic agen­da, the cur­rent admin­is­tra­tion decid­ed to update the series.

As the Edu­ca­tion Depart­ment pre­pared the new edi­tion, Cheney’s office reviewed drafts and pro­vid­ed mate­ri­als but the sec­ond lady was not per­son­al­ly involved, an aide said.

The ref­er­ences to the Nation­al His­to­ry Stan­dards were added at the Edu­ca­tion Depart­ment after Cheney’s office signed off on an ini­tial draft that did not men­tion them. Aspey said it was appar­ent­ly done for con­sis­ten­cy, because such stan­dards were referred to in the depart­men­t’s oth­er guide­books for parents.

Aspey said men­tion of the stan­dards implied offi­cial approval. “We don’t endorse Nation­al Stan­dards for His­to­ry, and the doc­u­ment that was print­ed is not an accu­rate reflec­tion of the pol­i­cy of the gov­ern­ment right now,” she said.

New York Uni­ver­si­ty edu­ca­tor Diane Rav­itch, who launched the “Help­ing Your Child Learn” series of pub­li­ca­tions as a for­mer high-rank­ing Edu­ca­tion Depart­ment offi­cial, said it was a mis­take to sug­gest that the his­to­ry stan­dards were a tem­plate for the country.

Nonethe­less, Rav­itch said, “I would have had a hard time recall­ing [the book­let], because I think the recall makes a big issue of some­thing nobody would have paid atten­tion to otherwise.”
© Copy­right 2004 Los Ange­les Times

Cyn is Rick's wife, Katie's Mom, and Esther & Oliver's Mémé. She's also a professional geek, avid reader, fledgling coder, enthusiastic gamer (TTRPGs), occasional singer, and devoted stitcher.
Posts created 4259

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Posts

Begin typing your search term above and press enter to search. Press ESC to cancel.

Back To Top