Warning: Fat Lady Ahead

I am a fat per­son. There. I’ve said it. Did it shock you?

I’m fat. I’m also tall, fair-skinned, and green-eyed. At the moment, my hair is dark brown, with more and more sil­ver around my face and spread­ing through­out (and some­times, there’s pur­ple over the sil­ver bits). I have a strong, pleas­ant voice, ter­ri­ble eye­sight, straight teeth, long fin­gers, and high cheek­bones. Why is it that none of that mat­ters as much or is as mem­o­rable as the fact that I’m fat?

Many peo­ple seem to think fat is a dirty word. They’ll dance around it, try to avoid the sub­ject, get embar­rassed, and even argue when a fat per­son refers to her­self as fat. I don’t real­ly under­stand why, but I think it’s tied in with our soci­ety’s dys­func­tion­al atti­tudes about bod­ies, espe­cial­ly wom­en’s bod­ies, in general.

Fat isn’t a moral issue. The word in and of itself isn’t an insult. It’s a descrip­tion. Humans come in lots of varieties—tall, short, brown, pink, slender—and fat—and they’re all equal­ly wonderful.

I did­n’t choose to be fat. I did choose to get off the diet­ing mer­ry-go-round some­time in the mid-’90s because both per­son­al expe­ri­ence and a mul­ti­tude of med­ical stud­ies have shown that diet­ing sim­ply does not work and is not healthy.

First time bride, all innocent and new
I was­n’t always fat. I only weighed about 120 pounds (a size 6/8 for me) when I was 18, but I remem­ber think­ing that I looked like a cow, and could­n’t be attrac­tive until I got rid of those hor­ri­ble hip and rib bones.1I know the term for that now! It’s Body Dys­mor­phic Dis­or­der. I did­n’t have it any­where near as bad as some peo­ple do, but I cer­tain­ly had it. (I’ve had peo­ple refuse to believe that I was ever that weight, and the pho­to is post­ed as proof. It was not a healthy weight for me, but the pic­tures look good.) It took a seri­ous eat­ing dis­or­der to get to and main­tain that weight. I was ane­mic and con­stant­ly light-head­ed. I passed out with embar­rass­ing fre­quen­cy. Because I know how much I was able to hide from my friends and fam­i­ly, I don’t find it too sur­pris­ing that addicts and oth­ers with big secrets can also hide a great deal.

I’m much hap­pi­er with myself and my body now than then, and I know I’m health­i­er. No, I haven’t man­aged to ful­ly over­come the anti-fat pro­gram­ming that’s all around me. I still have things to work on. There are days when I don’t like my body when I’m tempt­ed to try again to lose weight. Sizeist remarks still get to me at times—but those times are becom­ing rar­er and rarer.

I hope more and more peo­ple start under­stand­ing that real beau­ty is far more than some­thing you can weigh and mea­sure, and I know that it is impor­tant to work on bring­ing that mes­sage to every­one. The aver­age size woman in the U.S. is get­ting taller and larg­er, accord­ing to every sta­tis­tic I’ve read. Instead of a size six (what dress­mak­ers once claimed was “aver­age”), the true aver­age is more a 14/16 now. Yet the “aver­age” actress gets small­er and small­er, with women like Courteney Cox and Teri Hatch­er sup­pos­ed­ly wear­ing size 2 dress­es and some even wear­ing size 0!

Why do most women who are a size 16 believe them­selves to be hor­ri­bly big now? Because today’s press shoves images of women like Hatch­er and Cox at us as if they were average—and they’re not. They nev­er have been. They nev­er will be.

There’s a per­fect­ly good rea­son that my for­mer moth­er-in-law, who had always worn a size 2, always had a ter­ri­ble time find­ing adult clothes in her size. Such tiny peo­ple sim­ply aren’t aver­age. They are uncommon.

It’s unhealthy for the great major­i­ty of us, whose bod­ies were nev­er intend­ed to be that small, to attempt to achieve such sizes. The expec­ta­tion is unre­al­is­tic, and the pres­sure of try­ing to attain the unat­tain­able is killing too many girls.

There’s some­thing ter­ri­bly wrong when eighty per­cent of the ten-year-old girls in our coun­try have already been on a diet. Eat­ing dis­or­ders are so com­mon in young women that bulim­ia isn’t even some­thing to be ashamed of in many mid­dle and high school cliques. The Octo­ber 1997 issue of Par­ent­ing mag­a­zine fea­tured an arti­cle enti­tled “Why Even Six-Year-Olds Are Diet­ing,” It cit­ed stud­ies show­ing that most girls were “becom­ing anx­ious about food and their physiques long before adolescence—as young as age 5 or 6. Their behav­ior may fall short of clin­i­cal anorex­ia or bulim­ia, but it shows clear hall­marks of dis­rupt­ed eating—chronic diet­ing, obsess­ing about food and weight, neg­a­tive body image.” It went on to men­tion a Uni­ver­si­ty of Flori­da study that found that 42% of the six and sev­en-year-old girls they stud­ied want­ed to be thinner.

Good Girls Don’t Get Fat by body image expert Dr. Robyn Sil­ver­man is a fan­tas­tic read that I rec­om­mend to every­one, fat or oth­er­wise, espe­cial­ly par­ents. Here’s my detailed review of the book.

Ellyn Sat­ter, R.D., author of How to Get Your Kid to Eat…But Not Too Much2Look, the prob­lem is even demon­strat­ed in the title of the book!, sees a direct con­nec­tion between the increas­ing inci­dence of diet­ing in pread­o­les­cents and obe­si­ty in chil­dren. She says, “There is a sta­tis­ti­cal cor­re­la­tion between diet­ing and fat­ness. Once you start restrict­ing kids’ intake, they may get fright­ened and food-pre­oc­cu­pied, and pos­si­bly become com­pul­sive eaters, stuff­ing them­selves as if they’re starved.”

Does all this mean that I don’t think any­body should diet or lose weight, or that I have some­thing against peo­ple who are nat­u­ral­ly thin­ner than I am? No, of course not. I’m a pro­po­nent of Health at Every Size, which is best explained in Lin­do Bacon’s excel­lent book, Health At Every Size: The Sur­pris­ing Truth About Your Weight. If some­one wants to lose weight, that’s his or her busi­ness. I do think it’s more effec­tive for peo­ple to try to improve their health in gen­er­al, and some­times mak­ing changes like increas­ing activ­i­ty lev­els and mak­ing health­i­er food choic­es will result in a weight loss—but it does­n’t result in a weight loss, big or small, for every­one, due to meta­bol­ic dif­fer­ences. I don’t go around encour­ag­ing peo­ple to gain or lose weight—that’s per­son­al. I have noth­ing against any­one with regard to their looks, no mat­ter how much they may dif­fer from or resem­ble me in size, height, col­or­ing, etc. I don’t want my chil­dren try­ing to diet their hip bones away, or starv­ing them­selves until their metab­o­lism is all screwed up try­ing to achieve skele­tal pro­files. I want to encour­age greater accep­tance of diver­si­ty in sizes, just as we’ve start­ed see­ing more accep­tance of eth­nic diver­si­ty. Even bet­ter, I’d like to see more accep­tance of the idea that who you are is more impor­tant than what you look like—to achieve a bal­ance that val­ues bod­ies, minds, and souls togeth­er and hon­ors differences.

Dr. Bacon also wrote Body Respect: What Con­ven­tion­al Health Books Get Wrong, Leave Out, and Just Plain Fail to Under­stand about Weight, which is anoth­er won­der­ful, worth­while book.

For­tu­nate­ly, there is grow­ing aware­ness of this prob­lem and a grow­ing size accep­tance move­ment in the U.S. Groups like NAAFA have been around for years, but main­stream jour­nal­ists have real­ly paid lit­tle atten­tion to these prob­lems until now. Even Peo­ple Mag­a­zine has done an arti­cle about eat­ing dis­or­ders and how much of the prob­lem is caused by the unre­al­is­ti­cal­ly thin mod­els and actress­es most often fea­tured on tele­vi­sion and in oth­er mass media forums. In fact, they did a sec­ond cov­er arti­cle, this one on promi­nent celebri­ties who are larg­er than the norm for Hol­ly­wood, like Rosie O’Don­nell and Delta Burke.

Camryn Manheim photoI hap­pen to think Cam­ryn Man­heim is one of the sex­i­est pub­lic fig­ures around. If a genie appeared and gave me a choice of look­ing like Man­heim or Cal­ista Flock­hart, I would­n’t even have to con­sid­er it—I’d pick Cam­ryn. I read Wake Up! I’m Fat! right after it was released, and it was very enjoy­able. I’ve read sev­er­al arti­cles about Cam­ryn recently—my favorite was in Girl­friends Magazine—the pho­to here is from their cov­er (hint to mag­a­zine pub­lish­ers: yes, if you put Cam­ryn on the cov­er of just about any­thing, I’ll buy it). She’s won an Emmy and a Gold­en Globe for her role on The Prac­tice, as well as appear­ing in sev­er­al movies and stage shows. If you want more of her, Joe Sher­lock has gath­ered just about every­thing relat­ed to Cam­ryn on his web­site (and also has info about oth­er BBWs in media).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Begin typing your search term above and press enter to search. Press ESC to cancel.

Back To Top