Blended Family: Homeschooling and Public Schooling in Our Household

An article from about 2000–2001

We have a blend­ed family—me, my part­ner Sam, my daugh­ter Katie, his son Rowan and his daugh­ter Genevieve. There’s been so much writ­ten about blend­ing fam­i­lies that it’s hard­ly worth dis­cussing, but there’s one issue I haven’t real­ly seen addressed anywhere—combining home­school­ing and pub­lic school­ing in one family.

I home­school my daugh­ter. We absolute­ly love it, and it would be extreme­ly dif­fi­cult for us to go back to fol­low­ing some­body else’s sched­ule and some­body else’s choic­es about what she learns, when, and what sil­ly hoops she needs to jump through as far as tests and paper­work and dress. She jumped through those hoops extreme­ly well, but she’s blos­somed so much just in the year she’s been out of that envi­ron­ment that I can’t help but won­der what dam­age it did to her. And no, Katie does­n’t resent any­thing about not being in pub­lic school. She gets far more actu­al social time now than she did when she was in pub­lic school, and she enjoys mov­ing at her own pace and being able to study sub­jects that real­ly catch her fan­cy in-depth. Sev­er­al times, we’ve over­heard her con­vinc­ing oth­er kids that they should ask their par­ents to try homeschooling.

Sam’s ex-wife objects to home­school­ing. They have joint legal cus­tody, so the kids are in pub­lic school and there are ongo­ing nego­ti­a­tions about what will hap­pen in the future. They want to be home­schooled, as well—we had a tri­al of home­school­ing for every­body last sum­mer and it was a big hit with the entire fam­i­ly. The kids slept late in the morn­ings so they could stay up late when Sam was home in the evenings. They did some work dur­ing the day, but had lots of free time, as well, and worked with him on var­i­ous sub­jects when he got home. Sam had much more time with them, which made every­body hap­pi­er. We could go to Stone Moun­tain or a local muse­um or the library at the drop of the hat—and we did.

Those days are over ’til next sum­mer, though, and for now, Geni and Rowan have to get up each morn­ing and catch the bus. They dress by the school’s pre­scribed rules, sit in bor­ing class­rooms with 29 oth­er kids all day, are held back to the lev­el of the slow­est stu­dents in their class­es, and get very lit­tle indi­vid­ual atten­tion from their teach­ers or any oth­er adult through­out most of the day. When they get home, most of the day is gone, and they have home­work to fill the rest of it. They have very lit­tle time for play­ing, much less for sports, music or oth­er lessons, friends, etc.—just get­ting to check their email is often a big deal. Geni has had two field trips all year, and Rowan had none until his Probe (gift­ed) class went to the zoo sev­er­al times for a project. Geni is in a Girl Scout troop, but since all the oth­er girls in the troop are also in pub­lic school, the troop isn’t very active and nobody real­ly has time to do any more than meet every oth­er week.

In con­trast, Katie is as like­ly to be doing math wear­ing fairy wings and glit­ter as in jeans and a t‑shirt. She has bal­let and jazz dance class­es and is involved with a very active Girl Scout troop (full of oth­er home­schooled girls and led by home­school­ing par­ents). She’s had time to take Span­ish, dra­ma, and writ­ing class­es through a local home­school­ing co-op. She recent­ly added voice lessons, as well. She eats when she’s hun­gry, goes to the bath­room with­out ask­ing for per­mis­sion, and can go to the library just by say­ing “Mom­my, would you please take me to the library?” (because I’m usu­al­ly just as eager to go as she is.) While we’re always sure to be home by the time the school bus­es return Geni and Rowan to us, we have a lot of free­dom in what we do while they’re gone, and we enjoy it.

As you can imag­ine, the con­trast caus­es ten­sion in the fam­i­ly. It’s per­fect­ly rea­son­able that Geni and Rowan feel resent­ful when they’re rush­ing to get home­work done and Katie is play­ing or doing an art project or prac­tic­ing a dance rou­tine. They have to have very fixed bed­times, and she can stay up to look at the stars when we’re study­ing astron­o­my. She recent­ly fin­ished read­ing Mists of Aval­on and start­ed Lady of Aval­on, while they’re read­ing bor­ing, vocab­u­lary-con­trolled tripe which has no dis­tinc­tion oth­er than the dubi­ous one of being approved by the school board.

Geni and Rowan know that their father and I did not make the choic­es that require them to be in pub­lic school, but that does­n’t mean that they don’t get angry at us for enforc­ing the rules that inevitably accom­pa­ny being in pub­lic school. We can’t say, “that’s okay, you don’t have to do that assign­ment right now—let’s sit down and talk about…” because we aren’t their teach­ers and we don’t make up their aca­d­e­m­ic sched­ules (and we do not believe in under­min­ing their teach­ers). They have to go to bed in time to get enough sleep to get up and be fresh at X time in the morn­ing so they can get on the bus and go to school. If one of them isn’t at their best in the morn­ing, that’s just tough—that’s when school starts, and every­body has to run on that schedule.

What can we do about it? We keep try­ing to be as flex­i­ble as we can be while acknowl­edg­ing the real­i­ties of the sit­u­a­tion. We try to keep remind­ing the kids that we don’t real­ly have a choice in this mat­ter right now. We keep hop­ing that Geni and Rowan’s moth­er will change her mind—but we don’t plan on it. We cer­tain­ly don’t say “Hey, don’t blame me, blame your moth­er!” but it does­n’t have to be said for them to know it, and we do wor­ry that it will dam­age their rela­tion­ship with their mother.

Is it fair? No. Can we help it? No, no more than any blend­ed fam­i­ly can help things like some kids hav­ing involved, lov­ing grand­par­ents, and oth­er kids hard­ly know­ing their extend­ed fam­i­lies. Life isn’t always fair, and some kids have to learn that ear­li­er than oth­ers, despite the best efforts of their parents.

(And before peo­ple start rec­om­mend­ing that we go to court over this issue, the answer is no—it would result in dam­age to every­one con­cerned and enrich lawyers, but we don’t think it would be a last­ing res­o­lu­tion in any pos­i­tive sense.)

Last updat­ed May 10, 2001

2 thoughts on “Blended Family: Homeschooling and Public Schooling in Our Household

  1. Wow! I feel you big time. Poor kids that want to be home­schooled but can not due to the cir­cum­stances. I am cur­rent­ly in a heat­ed court sit­u­a­tion due to the fact the Pub­lic School Edu­ca­tion clear­ly has not worked for the past 7 years and home­school­ing should be an option on the table. Blend­ed fam­i­lies are not always so easy. Also still so much taboo around home­school­ing when tru­ly our fore­fa­thers home­schooled. Any­way thank you for this blog post.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Begin typing your search term above and press enter to search. Press ESC to cancel.

Back To Top