TechnoMom’s Home Education FAQ

What is tru­ly annoy­ing is that so many peo­ple have pre­con­ceived notions about home­school­ing and home­school­ers, but those who have been the most vocal in their oppo­si­tion to it seem to be the least will­ing to do any actu­al research or to lis­ten to any­thing that does­n’t agree with what they “know” about it (the “My mind’s made up, don’t both­er me with the facts!” crowd). And while these words prob­a­bly won’t ever be read by any of the peo­ple who’ve told me what a dread­ful mis­take I’m mak­ing, this is my chance to say them, at least, with­out inter­rup­tion. If even one per­son reads them hon­est­ly or gets any infor­ma­tion here, then it will have been worth the time it took to write this web page (above and beyond the sheer vent­ing val­ue, which is significant).

  • Is teach­ing your child at home real­ly legal? Don’t you have to be a cer­ti­fied teacher or something?
    In Geor­gia it cer­tain­ly is. In fact, some form of home edu­ca­tion is legal in every one of the Unit­ed States, although state laws do vary wide­ly. Geor­gia requires that I file a Dec­la­ra­tion of Intent with the school sys­tem each year as well as month­ly atten­dance reports. Geor­gia law states that chil­dren must be instruct­ed in read­ing, lan­guage arts, math­e­mat­ics, social stud­ies, and sci­ence. In Geor­gia, it is legal for a par­ent or guardian to teach his or her chil­dren as long as he or she has a high school diplo­ma or GED. Tutors may be hired to instruct chil­dren as long as they have a bach­e­lor’s degree, but need not be cer­ti­fied teachers.
  • Isn’t home­school­ing some­thing that only Chris­t­ian fun­da­men­tal­ists do?
    Nope. The move­ment to return edu­ca­tion to the home was­n’t even start­ed by Chris­t­ian fun­da­men­tal­ists in this coun­try, but by more lib­er­al thinkers who object­ed to the rigid­i­ty of the pub­lic schools. Gen­tle Spir­it mag­a­zine has done a mar­velous four-part series on the his­to­ry of home­school­ing in the US, and there’s no way I could do any­thing like the job Cheryl Seel­hoff already did in explain­ing it, but it seems to have been tak­en off the net.
    While Chris­t­ian home­school­ers became very vis­i­ble in the 1980s and 90s, there were always oth­er peo­ple edu­cat­ing their chil­dren home who either weren’t Chris­t­ian or were home­school­ing for rea­sons oth­er than reli­gion. Home­school­ing is get­ting far more main­stream now than ever—even Buffy the Vam­pire Slay­er asked her moth­er to con­sid­er it, say­ing “it’s not just for scary reli­gious peo­ple anymore.”

    Admit­ted­ly, it can be hard­er for peo­ple who aren’t con­ser­v­a­tive Chris­tians to find sup­port groups, prepack­aged cur­ricu­lum, umbrel­la schools, and oth­er resources to help with home­school­ing —but they are out there, and there are more and more resources all the time.

  • So home­school­ing has noth­ing to do with your reli­gious or oth­er beliefs?
    While reli­gious issues weren’t the pri­ma­ry rea­son for my deci­sion, they cer­tain­ly con­tributed to it. I live in the Bible Belt, and there’s a lot of de fac­to Chris­t­ian indoc­tri­na­tion that hap­pens even in pub­lic schools here. I pre­fer that my daugh­ter not get infor­ma­tion from school teach­ers that con­tra­dicts what she learns at home. I don’t hon­est­ly think there is any way to com­plete­ly sep­a­rate one’s beliefs from edu­ca­tion, so I believe that any­one who tru­ly wants her chil­dren edu­cat­ed accord­ing to her own belief sys­tem has to either be her chil­dren’s pri­ma­ry teacher or send her chil­dren to a school that is based on a phi­los­o­phy with which she agrees. My reli­gious beliefs aren’t those of the pre­dom­i­nant par­a­digm here in Geor­gia, so it makes sense for me to turn to homeschooling.

    As for beliefs oth­er than those that are strict­ly reli­gious, I don’t under­stand how any lib­er­tar­i­an can send his or her child to a gov­ern­ment school for indoc­tri­na­tion, or how any lib­er­al can do so in the South­east­ern U.S. I’ve also heard far too many sex­ist, racist, homo­pho­bic, look­ist and oth­er big­ot­ed remarks from school offi­cials to trust that they won’t be mak­ing such remarks to or in front of my child, and I don’t want her to pick up those poi­sons. (And if oth­er chil­dren make those remarks, school offi­cials sel­dom inter­vene or con­tra­dict the state­ments at all.)

  • What about social­iza­tion? How will she learn to get along with oth­er people?
    If you think much pos­i­tive social­iza­tion is hap­pen­ing in any aver­age school (pub­lic or pri­vate), you haven’t been in one late­ly. In the ele­men­tary schools that Katie, Rowan, and Geni have attend­ed, at least, the kids aren’t even allowed to talk to each oth­er most of the time in the cafe­te­ria. Talk­ing in the halls gets them in trou­ble, and they’re fre­quent­ly ordered to be silent on the bus­es to and from school. So where was that “social­iza­tion” hap­pen­ing? Oh, in the class­room. Right. Yeah, kids get lots of time to social­ize there.

    So, when the kids get any­thing like a recess, they have “social­iza­tion” time. Oh, and while wait­ing for the bus in the morn­ing. What’s that, maybe 45 min­utes a day? At most?

    So here my poor kid is, iso­lat­ed at home away from all oth­er kids. Except for Rowan and Geni, of course. And the many chil­dren in our neigh­bor­hood (I’m not kidding—there were about 25 neigh­bor­hood kids hang­ing out around the place while we were mov­ing in!) Oh, and the kids she sees in the dra­ma, dance and Span­ish class­es she takes. And the oth­er mem­bers of her Girls Scout troop, and the kids she sees as home­school­ing sup­port group play­days and those she sees week­ly at soc­cer prac­tices and games. Oh, and there are the kids (who don’t live in the neigh­bor­hood) who gath­er at our place for D&D games every oth­er week­end or so. Yep, I’m real­ly wor­ried about Katie being iso­lat­ed from her peers.

    In all hon­esty, around Atlanta, at least, it’s more dif­fi­cult to decide which activ­i­ties and social oppor­tu­ni­ties we’re going to par­tic­i­pate in and to keep from being over­com­mit­ted than it is to find oppor­tu­ni­ties for socialization.

    Of course, the oth­er kids she inter­acts with aren’t all exact­ly her age, and they would­n’t all be in the same grade with her if she knew them through a school set­ting. And pret­ty much all of the inter­ac­tions she has with oth­er kids are super­vised by me, Sam, and/or oth­er trust­ed adults. I can’t quite bring myself to think that’s a bad thing. Just how many times in your life after for­mal school­ing have you been in groups of peo­ple who were all with­in twelve months of your own age? Does­n’t hap­pen much in the real world, does it? Katie is learn­ing to inter­act with old­er and younger kids, kids her age, and adults of var­i­ous ages—just like she’ll be doing for the rest of her life.

  • How can you pos­si­bly teach your child as well as pro­fes­sion­al edu­ca­tors could?
    Hon­est­ly, I can do bet­ter. I know her, have known her all her life, and always know what’s hap­pen­ing in her life that might affect for­mal stud­ies. I have one-on-one time with her and don’t need to spend time cod­dling those who aren’t get­ting some­thing as quick­ly as she does or accom­mo­dat­ing stu­dents with learn­ing or behav­ioral dis­abil­i­ties. I’m able to choose the mate­r­i­al that reflects her interests—and mine—and we can spend as much time as we like on a top­ic rather than fol­low­ing a school’s strict cal­en­dar. I don’t have to get any­body’s per­mis­sion or arrange for a bus to take us to a muse­um, book­store, or any­where else, or try to sched­ule library vis­its so they don’t con­flict with oth­er class­es time there. I love her, and I have far more rea­son to care pas­sion­ate­ly about her edu­ca­tion than any hired pro­fes­sion­al of any sort ever will.

    Yes, there are things that I don’t know, and that I may not be able to teach her. There are, how­ev­er, many class­es for home­school­ers for just that rea­son and there are cer­tain­ly many pri­vate tutors avail­able. There are also oth­er peo­ple in our lives who know many things that I don’t know, and who Katie and I will approach for help in learn­ing those things.

    While it’s dif­fi­cult to gath­er sta­tis­tics on home­school­ers for sev­er­al rea­sons, those that are avail­able show that home­school­ers con­sis­tent­ly out­per­form pub­lic schooled stu­dents on stan­dard­ized tests. His­tor­i­cal­ly, the lit­er­a­cy rate in the Unit­ed States has gone done since the advent of com­pul­so­ry school­ing. Think about it—when most peo­ple taught their chil­dren them­selves or sent them to church-spon­sored schools, the lit­er­a­cy rate was high­er than it is now, when free pub­lic schools are avail­able to every child in the US and par­ents are legal­ly required to obtain some sort of edu­ca­tion for their chil­dren. Why does that not sur­prise me at all?

  • You can’t pos­si­bly pro­vide the resources a school can!
    Oh, I beg to differ.
    • Com­put­er tech­nol­o­gy? Katie has access to a PC with inter­net access pret­ty much 24/7 with lit­tle to no wait­ing (and since we plan to expand our home LAN short­ly, what wait­ing there is now will soon be a thing of the past). Also, since it’s our equip­ment and our net­work, she gets to learn to work with the com­put­ers at a far deep­er lev­el than if she were sim­ply using sys­tems some­one else had set up for her, then for­bid­den her to change at all.
    • Lab equip­ment? She’s used a micro­scope and been able to do var­i­ous lab exper­i­ments here at home, and nev­er had that at school. Yes, those kinds of things will get more expen­sive as she gets old­er and more advanced in her stud­ies, but I don’t antic­i­pate any trou­ble find­ing access to any­thing she needs in Atlanta.
    • Books? We have more at home than in any class­room she’s ever entered. We buy both non-fic­tion and fic­tion books as the need (or whim) strikes. We also go to the pub­lic library sev­er­al times a week (which has far more resources than even the best school libraries).
    • Peri­od­i­cals? Well, there are usu­al­ly copies of two dif­fer­ent dai­ly news­pa­pers avail­able around here. In addi­tion, we are the Mag­a­zine Peo­ple. The ones that the kids read on a reg­u­lar basis that come to mind right away are: 

      I had no idea that there were so many mag­a­zines for kids when I was one—in fact, I don’t think there were. I knew about crap like Tiger Beat and Teen (mag­a­zines which do not come into this house­hold) but would have been fas­ci­nat­ed by New Moon. I know those mag­a­zines weren’t avail­able at my school and aren’t avail­able at the schools Geni and Rowan attend now. Of course, there are also quite a few pub­li­ca­tions around the house that aren’t mar­ket­ed to or writ­ten specif­i­cal­ly for chil­dren, and the kids read those as well sometimes—Rowan espe­cial­ly likes Discover.

    • Then there’s the whole fine arts thing —can’t for­get that. 
      • Visu­al arts? We have more art sup­plies (of high­er qual­i­ty) in this house at any giv­en moment than I saw in 12 years of pub­lic school­ing. Var­i­ous kinds of crayons and pens and oil pas­tels and col­ored pen­cils and paints and spe­cial draw­ing pen­cils and a whole mess of spe­cial paint brush­es (but we always seem to need a new one or two for each project) and what seems to be every kind of paper known to mankind (con­struc­tion, trac­ing, draw­ing, ban­ner, newsprint, fin­ger paint­ing, poster­board, grid­ded in var­i­ous fash­ions, spe­cial papers for the var­i­ous print­ers to make T‑shirt decals or mug inserts or what­ev­er caught some­one’s fan­cy this week). There are glues and glit­ters and stick­ers and sten­cils and stamps and ink pads—look, imag­ine going through the arts and crafts aisle at Zany Brainy and grab­bing some of every­thing. That’s what the craft sup­ply area looks like. I sup­pose one might argue that my needle­work sup­plies should­n’t be count­ed since I acquired most of them in my pur­suit of the stitch­ing hob­by going back to well before I had Katie. I con­sid­er them school sup­plies now, though, as the kids know there are box­es of fab­rics and fibers and bead and pat­terns and but­tons and rib­bons and glues and such that they can use to their hearts’ delight.
      • Music? Katie’s been sur­round­ed by good music since her con­cep­tion! We have an ungod­ly num­ber of CDs, cas­sette tapes, and even some old LPs on vinyl (I sus­pect the exis­tence of some 8‑track tapes in the garage, but I’m avoid­ing find­ing out for sure). The music avail­able here ranges from Bach to Rock­apel­la to Clan­nad to the Back­street Boys to Ani Difran­co. We have two met­al flutes, one wood­en flute, an oca­ri­na, a drag­on whis­tle, two very nice key­boards, a cou­ple of recorders, a dhoum­bek and var­i­ous small­er per­cus­sion instru­ments, and are work­ing on adding a real­ly good dig­i­tal piano to the mix so we can start play­ing with midi. We reg­u­lar­ly make music at home or with var­i­ous groups and will arrange any for­mal musi­cal instruc­tion in which the kids show inter­est. Katie has already had sev­er­al years of piano lessons and may return for fur­ther study. I would like for all of our chil­dren to take at least one year of piano sim­ply as a sol­id ground­ing for fur­ther musi­cal study or life­long music appre­ci­a­tion. As for mak­ing music with groups, there are home­school­ing choirs and bands in the Atlanta area as well as oth­er pos­si­bil­i­ties should any of the kids decide they’re interested.
      • Dra­ma. Oh yes, we’ve got dra­ma —good role­play­ing demands it, and the kids are get­ting bet­ter all the time! Katie’s also tak­ing a class with a group of oth­er home­school­ers, and is inter­est­ed in find­ing a more advanced class when this ses­sion is over—and adding voice instruc­tion. And we have trunks full of cool cos­tumes to be used in play­ing dress-up or stag­ing plays—I dreamed of hav­ing those kinds of things to play with as a child!
      • Dance. Katie has tak­en jazz and bal­let for five years. She’s con­tin­u­ing her study­ing of those dis­ci­plines and mov­ing on up in them.
    • Should the kids devel­op inter­ests in any­thing for which we don’t cur­rent­ly have mate­ri­als or equip­ment on hand, it’s quite easy for us to acquire or get access to what­ev­er is nec­es­sary for them to explore that inter­est. We don’t need to get approval from any­one or sub­mit bud­get pro­pos­als or seek grants to fund such pur­chas­es. We can just make it happen.
  • But there are all those field trips!
    How many field trips do your kids actu­al­ly go on a year? When they get there, how much time do they have to real­ly explore the place? In a total of ten years spent in pub­lic schools in the metro Atlanta area (three in Cobb Coun­ty, sev­en in Gwin­nett Coun­ty), I had one trip to the zoo and one to the Capi­tol Build­ing. (My two years in the city schools of Gads­den, Alaba­ma did­n’t include any field trip. Those were reserved for the spe­cial edu­ca­tion kids but they seemed to take a lot of them.)

    We have annu­al pass­es to Stone Moun­tain Park, Fern­bank Nat­ur­al His­to­ry Museum/Science Cen­ter, SciTrek, and Zoo Atlanta. Oth­er places we’ve vis­it­ed or are plan­ning to vis­it soon include the High Muse­um of Art, Atlanta His­to­ry Cen­ter, South­east­ern Rail­way Muse­um, Carter Cen­ter, Wren’s Nest, Michael C. Car­los Muse­um, Oglethor­pe Uni­ver­si­ty Muse­um, and the Ten­nessee Aquar­i­um. While we’re up in Ten­nessee, we’ll prob­a­bly go down to Ruby Falls and see Rock City and who knows what else. We can do that, because nobody makes our sched­ule but us. We’ve already had more “field trips” in our few months of offi­cial home­school­ing, both with groups and as a fam­i­ly, than I had in my entire school career.

  • Uh, gift­ed pro­grams! She’s miss­ing out on the gift­ed programs!
    Well no, she’s not. In our coun­ty, at the ele­men­tary lev­el at least, what used to be called the “gift­ed pro­gram” is a pull-out pro­gram. Kids are tak­en out of their nor­mal class­rooms and go to a spe­cial class once a week to engage in fair­ly sil­ly games and the occa­sion­al extra assign­ment. Around the sev­enth grade, as I under­stand it, there are some inte­grat­ed class­es for the chil­dren in those pro­grams in some schools—advanced math or social studies—but not at all mid­dle schools, and not for all stu­dents. Every­thing we do is part of the “gift­ed pro­gram” because it’s all set at a pace and lev­el designed to engage my gift­ed child. As for social­iz­ing with oth­er gift­ed chil­dren, there’s anoth­er gift­ed child in this house­hold and most of our friends’ chil­dren are labeled gift­ed by their var­i­ous schools. Should we find the need for more for­mal inter­ac­tion, we’ll turn to Men­sa or a sim­i­lar organization.
  • Come on, you have to admit that she’s miss­ing some­thing by not being in school.
    Oh, absolute­ly! Cafe­te­ria food. Sex­u­al harass­ment (yes, it does start that ear­ly). Peer pres­sure to smoke, drink alco­hol or use recre­ation­al drugs. Homo­pho­bia. Sub­sti­tute teach­ers who have no cre­den­tials oth­er than get­ting to the school if they’re called. Hav­ing to get permission—or being denied permission—to take care of basic bod­i­ly func­tions like going to the bath­room. Being told to stop as soon as she’s got­ten inter­est­ed in a sub­ject because the sched­uled 20 min­utes is up. Feel­ing like she isn’t as good as some­one else because she does­n’t look like the cur­rent ide­al, or does­n’t have the hottest clothes, or does­n’t live in the right neigh­bor­hood, or whatever—or being pres­sured to not asso­ciate with some­one else for those rea­sons. Get­ting the idea that she’d bet­ter hide her intel­li­gence because it’s not fem­i­nine, or because being smart just isn’t cool. Bul­lies. Those love­ly fre­quent lice checks, because some par­ents just won’t ever take care of their chil­dren’s infes­ta­tions. Liv­ing on some­one else’s sched­ule. Yep, hap­pi­ly, she’s miss­ing lots of things that most peo­ple take for grant­ed in their chil­dren’s lives.

    After read­ing Mary Pipher’s books Reviv­ing Ophe­lia and The Shel­ter of Each Oth­er, and remem­ber­ing the cli­mate when I was in school in the 70s to mid-80s and know­ing that things have only got­ten worse, I had no doubts about the kinds of things I want­ed my daugh­ter to miss. And Sense of Self: Lis­ten­ing to Home­schooled Ado­les­cent Girls by Susan Shef­fer was one of many sources that helped me to real­ize that deschool­ing Katie would be health­i­er for her than pub­lic or pri­vate schooling.

    There’s also the issue of high pro­file vio­lence. One month after the infa­mous Columbine shoot­ings, a kid pulled out a gun at Her­itage High School in Cony­ers, GA (Sam’s alma mater), and start­ed shoot­ing his class­mates. That same week, a bomb was found—yes, a real one, not a fake one—in a bath­room at Berk­mar High School in Lil­burn, GA (my alma mater). I don’t want my child in a school where any freak want­i­ng a tar­get-rich envi­ron­ment can walk in and start shoot­ing (or set off bombs, etc.). Yes, some­body could come into our home and start shooting—but it’s unlike­ly a stranger would choose our home as a tar­get. I know that my abil­i­ty to pro­tect my child when she’s with me or in our home is far greater than any school’s abil­i­ty to pro­tect her.

  • But you can’t be sure she’s get­ting an edu­ca­tion as good as what she’d get in school!
    Actu­al­ly, I can be sure she’s get­ting a far bet­ter edu­ca­tion than she would get in the local schools. I’m using the local school board­’s cur­ricu­lum stan­dards for each grade as the absolute min­i­mum. Far more of our mate­r­i­al comes from a com­bi­na­tion of The Well Trained Mind: A Par­en­t’s Guide to Clas­si­cal Edu­ca­tion by Jessie Wise and Susan Wise Bauer and the Core Knowl­edge Foun­da­tion’s mate­ri­als. The school’s stan­dards don’t come any­where near the breadth or depth of the stan­dards set forth in WTM or by the CK Foundation.
  • The only peo­ple who pull their kids out of school are the ones whose kids are hav­ing prob­lems there, or who did­n’t do well in school them­selves, right?
    No, that isn’t the case for us or the vast major­i­ty of home­school­ers we’ve encoun­tered. Katie was a straight “A” stu­dent, nev­er had one dis­ci­pline prob­lem, and had lots of friends at school. Even though she missed many days of third grade due to her father’s ill­ness and death she was a straight‑A stu­dent and was nev­er chal­lenged aca­d­e­m­i­cal­ly in the slight­est. I was the vale­dic­to­ri­an of my high school class, was involved in many activ­i­ties, and had plen­ty of friends. The fact that both Katie and I were good at jump­ing through the hoops the schools set up does­n’t mean we think they meant a great deal or were set high enough.
  • How can you stand to spend that much time with your kid?
    That’s the ques­tion that always shocks me and tells me a lot more about the per­son ask­ing (and, prob­a­bly, his or her child) than my answer can ever tell him. If you don’t like spend­ing that much time with your child because you just don’t like being around chil­dren much, why did you have a child in the first place? If you don’t like spend­ing that much time with your kid because of how he or she behaves, why haven’t you both­ered to raise a per­son who is pleas­ant com­pa­ny? News flash: I love spend­ing time with my daugh­ter! She’s a great per­son to be with! And her father and I actu­al­ly thought out the fact that we want­ed to raise a well-behaved, intel­li­gent, thought­ful, fun-lov­ing per­son well before we ever had a kid!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Begin typing your search term above and press enter to search. Press ESC to cancel.

Back To Top
%d bloggers like this: