Why I Educated My Daughter at Home (long answer)

Back around 1985, well before I even had a child, I some­how came across Mary Pride’s Big Book of Home Learn­ing. It’s out of print now (though she’s expand­ed it to many vol­umes in new­er ver­sions), but it fas­ci­nat­ed me. Here was a whole book list­ing and review­ing resources for par­ents teach­ing their chil­dren at home rather than send­ing them to school —and appar­ent­ly that was legal! I had nev­er heard of home­school­ing before and had to know more. I read every­thing I could find and knew then that when I did have chil­dren, that’s what I want­ed for them.

By the time I did have a child in 1990, my reli­gious views had cer­tain­ly changed a lot, but my opin­ions on home­school­ing had not. Unfor­tu­nate­ly, well before Katie was ready for school, her father and I divorced. For sev­er­al rea­sons, it was­n’t pos­si­ble for me to home­school her. She attend­ed pub­lic school until the 2000–2001 school year when I offi­cial­ly with­drew her.

Her father and I were both very involved in her edu­ca­tion, and nei­ther of us was sat­is­fied with her only meet­ing the stan­dards the school set for her. We want­ed more for Katie. Unfor­tu­nate­ly, that meant she was gen­er­al­ly well ahead of her class and, frankly, bored. While Katie nev­er had any kind of prob­lems at school aca­d­e­m­i­cal­ly or social­ly, she was inter­est­ed in learn­ing at home so she could go fur­ther rather than wait­ing for her chrono­log­i­cal peers.

Sev­er­al things changed in our lives in 1999. Katie’s father died after bat­tling leukemia for sev­er­al years. Katie devel­oped fibromyal­gia (not least due to the stress of her father’s ill­ness and death, I believe) and start­ed miss­ing a lot of school. And we for­mal­ly com­bined our lit­tle house­hold with that of Sam (my life part­ner) and his chil­dren Rowan and Genevieve.

Over the sum­mer of 2000, we had a tri­al of home­school­ing as a fam­i­ly. All of us enjoyed it and want­ed to con­tin­ue. Katie did not return to pub­lic school that fall.

My fam­i­ly, espe­cial­ly my moth­er’s fam­i­ly, has a strong tra­di­tion of work­ing in pub­lic schools. (In fact, every female I can think of in my moth­er’s fam­i­ly who has gone to col­lege got a degree in edu­ca­tion or music edu­ca­tion.) From past con­ver­sa­tions, I knew that they would not be hap­py and they weren’t. Katie, how­ev­er, thrived, and that was far more impor­tant to me than the approval of the extend­ed fam­i­ly. I found it iron­ic that some of my strongest moti­va­tions for edu­cat­ing Katie at home came from the war sto­ries I heard from fam­i­ly mem­bers about what goes on in the pub­lic schools—but because putting chil­dren in school is the “nor­mal” thing to do, they still found my deci­sion to home­school Katie surprising.

Sam’s fam­i­ly had a past expe­ri­ence with home­school­ing that was­n’t entire­ly pos­i­tive, so they weren’t too hap­py to hear about this deci­sion either.

Peo­ple kept ask­ing me why I would want to pull Katie out of school. They fig­ured that if I just did­n’t like the pub­lic school sys­tem, I should have put her in a pri­vate school. Every­one asked about social­iza­tion, assum­ing she would some­how be crip­pled social­ly and miss out on being with her arti­fi­cial­ly age-seg­re­gat­ed group in a school. Maybe they thought she’d for­get how to spend her days stand­ing in lines and respond­ing to bells? And how could I pos­si­bly think that I could teach her as well as all those cre­den­tialed teach­ers, or come up with the same kinds of resources she’d be able to access in school? I was asked how it could even be legal for me to teach Katie—I did­n’t have a col­lege degree, have nev­er even con­sid­ered tak­ing an edu­ca­tion course, and cer­tain­ly did­n’t have a teacher’s cer­tifi­cate. Some peo­ple asked why I would want to spend that much time with my child, as if her com­pa­ny was a bur­den to be borne, rather than a joy to be sought out!

The few who had been exposed to the idea of home­school­ing saw it as some­thing done by extreme­ly con­ser­v­a­tive Chris­tians (like Chris­t­ian Recon­struc­tion­ists) and assumed that I must have decid­ed to shel­ter my child from the sup­posed new age/secular human­ist con­spir­a­cy being car­ried out through the schools by those peo­ple.

I replied to all of those ques­tions and con­cerns but found that those ask­ing sel­dom real­ly lis­ten to the answers. That’s okay, if frus­trat­ing. I had to do what I believed was best for my child, and I hon­est­ly thought that home edu­ca­tion was the best edu­ca­tion for her. Every­thing we did was tai­lored to her and to our fam­i­ly, and she spent most of her hours with the per­son who knew and loved her best, and whose stan­dards of achieve­ment for her are far more demand­ing than the stan­dards set up by the school sys­tem. She was in a safe, nur­tur­ing envi­ron­ment, sur­round­ed by all sorts of things to use or read or play with or lis­ten to at her own pace. We lived life accord­ing to our fam­i­ly’s sched­ules and pri­or­i­ties, and we were able to do things like dance and Span­ish and dra­ma that were either dif­fi­cult or out of the ques­tion when she was in pub­lic school.

Some of my favorite things about hav­ing Katie at home rather than in school:

  • If we decid­ed to go hike up Stone Moun­tain one day with our books in our back­packs on the spur of the moment, that’s what we did.
  • Or we might decide to stay home and read all day, or go swim at the YMCA, or go use our mem­ber­ship at Fern­bank.
  • There were days when Katie did­n’t want to leave the PC because she was writ­ing some­thing and did­n’t want to stop the flow—and I could let her just work unin­ter­rupt­ed and enjoy it.
  • If we decid­ed to stay out look­ing at the stars (that’s “study­ing astron­o­my” if you want to get for­mal about it) we could do so, with­out wor­ry­ing about how late it got, because we don’t need to get up to catch a school bus in the morning.

And it was all okay because we were learn­ing all the time. There’s no way that any school, pub­lic or pri­vate, could ever pro­vide the same sit­u­a­tion for any child. It just isn’t pos­si­ble. But I could do it at home, so I did.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Begin typing your search term above and press enter to search. Press ESC to cancel.

Back To Top