Can’t Have It Both Ways

Tough by Leon Wieseltier

A war that asked for a quick­en­ing of con­science can­not now ask for a relax­ing of it.…

But what about the death of Israeli chil­dren at the hands of Pales­tini­ans? I resent the ques­tion for its assump­tion that sym­pa­thy is com­pro­mis­ing, a moral defor­ma­tion, a kind of infi­deli­ty; that decen­cy should accept polit­i­cal direc­tion; that you can be sick­ened by Pales­tin­ian chil­dren with guns or by Pales­tin­ian chil­dren in shrouds, but you can­not be sick­ened by both.…

The quan­daries of humane­ness in wartime explod­ed into scan­dal in Israel last week, when Tom­my Lapid, the min­is­ter of jus­tice, report­ed on the radio that at a meet­ing of the Cab­i­net, at which he opposed the demo­li­tion of more Pales­tin­ian homes in Gaza, he had remarked that “I did think, when I saw a pic­ture on the TV of an old woman on all fours in the ruins of her home look­ing under floor tiles for her medicines—I did think ‘What would I say if it were my grand­moth­er?’ ” Lapid’s grand­moth­er per­ished in the Holo­caust, and so the denun­ci­a­tions began. Lapid, it was said, had com­pared Israelis to Nazis, which is to say, he had com­mit­ted the mor­tal sin of moral equiv­a­lence. His words were cer­tain­ly fierce, but they came from his heart and not from his head, and their ori­gins in his heart do not embar­rass them. Plain­ly Lapid does not believe that he sits in a gov­ern­ment of Himm­lers. He mere­ly took pity on an old woman in a cat­a­stro­phe because she remind­ed him of an old woman in a cat­a­stro­phe. If no adver­si­ty can be likened to the Jew­ish adver­si­ty of the 1930s and 1940s, then all the instruc­tion about the moral cen­tral­i­ty of the Holo­caust will have the per­verse effect of strip­ping the Holo­caust of its moral cen­tral­i­ty, since it will no longer serve as a ref­er­ence point in the analy­sis of con­tem­po­rary evil.

Cyn is Rick's wife, Katie's Mom, and Esther & Oliver's Mémé. She's also a professional geek, avid reader, fledgling coder, enthusiastic gamer (TTRPGs), occasional singer, and devoted stitcher.
Posts created 4259

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Posts

Begin typing your search term above and press enter to search. Press ESC to cancel.

Back To Top