Orwellian Editing of the Congressional Record

This is the sec­ond instance I’ve heard of in the last six months where­in the Con­gres­sion­al Record has been edit­ed to reflect a par­tic­u­lar par­ty’s views.

What­ev­er one thinks of Rep­re­sen­ta­tive Brown’s state­ments, I find that kind of rewrit­ing of offi­cial records to be extreme­ly upset­ting and believe them to be dangerous.


George Orwell’s famous warn­ing that a pow­er­ful polit­i­cal par­ty could rewrite his­to­ry has once again been proven prophetic.

Just last Thurs­day, Flori­da Con­gress­woman Cor­rine Brown chas­tised the House of Rep­re­sen­ta­tives for reject­ing a request to allow the Unit­ed Nations to mon­i­tor the 2004 pres­i­den­tial elec­tions. In her speech, she accused House Repub­li­cans of help­ing Bush and Cheney steal the 2000 elec­tion in a coup d’e­tat, and she argued pas­sion­ate­ly that we could not let it hap­pen again.

How did the House of Rep­re­sen­ta­tives respond? The Repub­li­can lead­er­ship accused her of being “out of order,” and the Repub­li­can major­i­ty shout­ed her down. Then the House Repub­li­cans went a step fur­ther and vot­ed to have the con­gress­wom­an’s com­ments com­plete­ly strick­en from the Con­gres­sion­al Record. In a move too brazen even for Orwell’s Big Broth­er, the whole event was sim­ply erased. Gone. Nev­er happened.

Sur­prised you haven’t heard about it? Don’t be. The cen­sure of Con­gress­woman Brown is an egre­gious abuse of pow­er, not to men­tion a vio­la­tion of the Con­gress­wom­an’s free speech, yet the event has been all but ignored by the cor­po­rate media. Although NBC did men­tion it the day after it occurred, their slant on the sto­ry was to focus mere­ly on the “out­burst” and the com­mo­tion it caused, rather than to address the dual issues of stolen elec­tions and cen­sored speech.

Video clips of Con­gress­woman Brown’s speech in the House are still avail­able on the Web, but if you’d like to see them you’ll have to act quick­ly. The Par­ty may soon move to remove and delete them. Try this link.

Brown lat­er said: “Strik­ing my words from the House floor is just one more exam­ple of the Repub­li­can Par­ty’s attempt to try and cov­er up what hap­pened dur­ing the 2000 elec­tion. When the words of Cor­rine Brown are strick­en from the floor, so is the voice of her 600,000 con­stituents in Flori­da’s 3rd Con­gres­sion­al District.”

Want to DO some­thing about this? The pro­gres­sive web­site Buzzflash.com has pro­vid­ed the fol­low­ing list of actions you can take. The very first thing you should do, of course, is for­ward this mes­sage to every­one you know. Then get busy on the rest.

1. Write NBC news and sug­gest that this sto­ry was­n’t about an “out­burst.” The sto­ry should have been about the fact that an elect­ed Representative’s com­ments were stricken. 

2. Write a let­ter to your favorite polit­i­cal TV show or polit­i­cal writer and ask them to cov­er this part of the story.

3. Write to your elect­ed Rep­re­sen­ta­tive and express your feel­ings about Brown’s com­ments being strick­en. Be sure to empha­size that you sup­port the orig­i­nal request for some kind of mon­i­tor­ing to occur. (See our recent newslet­ter on the sub­ject elec­tion mon­i­tor­ing here.

4. Write Rep­re­sen­ta­tive Brown. She could prob­a­bly use some support.

Allow us to switch gears for a moment and turn to the sub­ject of film. Our last newslet­ter men­tioned sev­er­al promis­ing doc­u­men­taries now play­ing around the nation. A num­ber of sub­scribers quick­ly respond­ed to inform us that we had neglect­ed to men­tion a few.

Here is an updat­ed list of pro­gres­sive doc­u­men­tary films that present evi­dence and points of view that you’ll nev­er get these days from the main­stream cor­po­rate media. We rec­om­mend that you not only see these films but that you gath­er friends and acquain­tances to see the films togeth­er and to dis­cuss them afterward.

Fahren­heit 9/11. Michael Moore deft­ly con­nects the dots between the Bush admin­is­tra­tion (and fam­i­ly), its oil wealth, and the Sau­di monar­chy. Say what you want about Mr. Moore’s ego; there’s still no deny­ing his facts. Indeed, he has even post­ed his sources on the Web for all to see.

Con­trol Room. A tru­ly eye-open­ing behind-the-scenes look at the Al-Jazeera news net­work with a focus on how it cov­ered the U.S. inva­sion of Iraq. Since its cre­ation in 1996, Al-Jazeera has been reviled by Arab lead­ers and called “Osama bin-Lad­in’s mouth­piece” by the U.S. gov­ern­ment. Why so much ven­om for Al-Jazeera? Appar­ent­ly because it tells the truth. This net­work reveals the true hor­rors of war by refus­ing to cen­sor graph­ic images. It also offends nation­al lead­ers by duti­ful­ly air­ing dis­sent­ing points of view. Yes, it has a pro-Arab bias, but what most Amer­i­cans will find sur­pris­ing from this film is the extent to which Al-Jazeera attempts to report the news impar­tial­ly. Al-Jazeera, in
fact, comes far clos­er to the truth, at least with regard to Iraq, than most west­ern news agencies.

Out­foxed: Rupert Mur­doch’s War on Jour­nal­ism. An excel­lent com­pan­ion piece to Con­trol Room, this film uses inter­views with inside whistle­blow­ers and FOX’s own film footage to reveal the net­work’s noto­ri­ous right-wing bias and agen­da. Typ­i­cal of FOX’s style of report­ing is its cov­er­age of this doc­u­men­tary. Com­ment­ing on the film, FOX reporter Eric Shawn report­ed: “It’s unfair, it’s slant­ed, and it’s a hit job. And I haven’t even seen it yet.” Unfor­tu­nate­ly, this film is not play­ing in the­aters. Instead it is being dis­trib­uted online, and MoveOn.org is ask­ing peo­ple to orga­nize house par­ties this Sun­day, July 18, in which neigh­bors will gath­er togeth­er to view and dis­cuss the film. (Sor­ry for the late notice!) If you’re inter­est­ed in join­ing a house par­ty, vis­it this web page and type in your zip code. Then choose
a par­ty that’s con­ve­nient for you. (Inci­den­tal­ly, there’s a great piece on Bill O’Reil­ly’s sto­ry-spin­ning here, writ­ten by one of O’Reil­ly’s recent guests.)

The Cor­po­ra­tion. Cor­po­ra­tions dom­i­nate our world. More pow­er­ful than gov­ern­ments and reli­gious orga­ni­za­tions, cor­po­ra­tions more than any oth­er enti­ty threat­en our envi­ron­ment, health, finan­cial secu­ri­ty, and lib­er­ty. This new film doc­u­ments the rise of the cor­po­ra­tion and its pur­suit of pow­er and prof­its at the expense of lit­er­al­ly every­thing else. In the wake of the Enron, World­com, Glob­al Cross­ing, KPMG, Mer­rill Lynch, and Hal­libur­ton scan­dals (to name just a few), this film has nev­er been more impor­tant. (See our own work on the dan­gers of cor­po­rate pow­er here.)

Orwell Rolls in His Grave. What hap­pens to truth and to our knowl­edge of his­to­ry when only six huge and con­ser­v­a­tive cor­po­ra­tions con­trol what we see and hear on tele­vi­sion and radio? We get a ful­fill­ment of George Orwell’s dire prophe­cy about Big Broth­er, in which the gov­ern­ment and the media con­spire to keep the peo­ple in the dark. This new film exam­ines the cur­rent media cri­sis and its like­ly effect on democracy.


If this mes­sage was for­ward­ed to you by a friend and you would like to receive our newslet­ter direct­ly, send an email to subscribe@theemailactivist.org.

To read some back issues, some book reviews, or to get advice on how to con­tact your elect­ed rep­re­sen­ta­tives, vis­it us online.

Cur­rent Mood: 🙁wor­ried
Cyn is a proud Mommy & Mémé, professional geek, avid reader, fledgling coder, enthusiastic gamer (TTRPGs), occasional singer, and devoted stitcher.
Posts created 4241

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Posts

Begin typing your search term above and press enter to search. Press ESC to cancel.

Back To Top