Locked Down and Out in Rural Georgia

Michele is active on sev­er­al home­school­ing lists that I’m on as well. Some of her arti­cles have impressed me, espe­cial­ly the lit­er­ary math resource list. Most of the books she men­tioned are now on my wish list.

Per­son­al Voic­es: Locked Down and Out in Rur­al Georgia
By Lynn Hamil­ton, Alter­Net Jan­u­ary 2, 2004
A scratchy burst of sta­t­ic warns me that an announce­ment is about to burst in, unher­ald­ed, on my loudspeaker.“Attention, teach­ers. This is a lock down. Put your garbage cans in the hall out­side the room,” demands an anony­mous voice in a tone about as pleas­ant as that of a grack­le squawk.

It’s my first lock­down. As an Amer­i­can, I was, of course, brought up to be obe­di­ent to whichev­er voice threat­ens to be the ugli­est, so, with­out stop­ping to ask why I pick up the near­est waste can and put it out in the hall. My stu­dents, bet­ter versed in lock­down pro­to­col than I, are hand­ing anoth­er garbage pail, one I was pre­pared to over­look, up to the front of the class­room. I place that one out in the hall, too. I clamp down on the impulse to quip, “If you have any drugs or guns on you, for god’s sake, throw them in the waste bas­ket now.”

I try to resume teach­ing, but the next minute a man in a safe­ty blue shirt with weapons hang­ing off his sides has marched into my class­room and told all my stu­dents to get out in the hall and line up against the wall. They are told to take every­thing out of their pock­ets and hold it in their hands.

Sound like a max­i­mum-secu­ri­ty prison? A cadet acad­e­my in Ser­bia? Well, it’s not. This is all tak­ing place at Eff­in­g­ham Coun­ty High School, a pub­lic school in Spring­field, Geor­gia. Once stu­dents are lined up against the wall, the inspec­tor in safe­ty blue goes down the line, tak­ing wal­lets out of their hands and open­ing them up. Wal­lets in which stu­dents keep per­son­al items like mon­ey, iden­ti­fi­ca­tion, and fam­i­ly pic­tures. Stu­dents are also told to raise their arms so that an air­port-style detec­tor can search them for heavy met­als. To com­plete the pic­ture of unwar­rant­ed search and seizure, a Ger­man Shep­herd is pac­ing the hall, sniff­ing. The total pro­ce­dure takes only about sev­en or eight minutes.

As the last of my twen­ty-nine stu­dents files back into the room, psy­cho­log­i­cal­ly ready to do any­thing but learn, Safe­ty Blue heck­les me: “You get paid by the stu­dent?” Much has been said about the loss of civ­il rights in the after­math of Sep­tem­ber 11. Less is said about the after­math of the Columbine shoot­ings, an event that has rever­ber­at­ed through my coastal Geor­gia com­mu­ni­ty with appalling impli­ca­tions for civ­il lib­er­ties that no one seems pre­pared to question.

One of the scari­est things about my first lock­down was that, on return­ing to the class­room, only one stu­dent said some­thing like, “Yeah, that was a real­ly heinous vio­la­tion of my civ­il rights.” Anoth­er stu­dent point­ed out that lock­downs like this are use­less. When he got to school and saw all the police cars already there, he said to him­self, “Well, there’s going to be a lock­down.” If he’d had drugs or guns, he had ample oppor­tu­ni­ty to throw them out the win­dow or make a U‑turn and head back home. Oth­er stu­dents thought it was no big deal— a small price to pay for feel­ing safe. And, any­way, they’re used to it, now. They’re desen­si­tized. They’re desen­si­tized to lock­downs the way I’ve become desen­si­tized to air­port secu­ri­ty mea­sures, though those are much less inva­sive, prob­a­bly because the air­line indus­try is expect­ed to show a prof­it. Also because air­ports are under the close and con­stant scruti­ny of afflu­ent grown-ups who will tol­er­ate only so much rude­ness and delay in the name of pub­lic safety.

A quick romp through Lex­is Nex­is shows that oth­er com­mu­ni­ties are debat­ing how much inva­sion of pri­va­cy their stu­dents should endure in the name of pre­vent­ing a recur­rence of Columbine. Schools in Lords­burg, New Mex­i­co had to quit using drug dogs in what the Amer­i­can Civ­il Lib­er­ties Union argued were unrea­son­able search­es. The Lords­burg school sys­tem set­tled the mat­ter before it went to court. In Seat­tle, how­ev­er, the local ACLU decid­ed not to chal­lenge new pub­lic school search­es uti­liz­ing a labrador retriev­er. Anoth­er thing I found inter­est­ing is that the term “lock­down,” though wide­ly used in pub­lic schools across Amer­i­ca, means very dif­fer­ent things in dif­fer­ent regions. In the Colum­bus, Ohio area, “lock­down” refers to timed drills in which teach­ers herd stu­dents into their class­rooms, turn off the lights, and close blinds. The pur­pose of these drills is to be pre­pared in the case of an emer­gency like a vio­lent attack on the school, whether per­pe­trat­ed by stu­dents or terrorists.

A Man­as­sas, Mary­land news­pa­per described local schools as stag­ing a “lock­down” when the schools can­celed out­door activ­i­ties, locked the doors, and asked for iden­ti­fi­ca­tion of any­one enter­ing the build­ings. This was a one-time event, imple­ment­ed at the advice of the local police in response to an actu­al threat. By con­trast, the Eff­in­g­ham Coun­ty lock­downs are con­duct­ed ran­dom­ly, i.e. with­out the demon­stra­ble cause that our law gen­er­al­ly requires to jus­ti­fy a search and an inva­sion of pri­va­cy. One thing that trou­bles me is that these lock­downs are not scru­ti­nized by the pub­lic at large, as are air­port secu­ri­ty mea­sures. I wor­ry about adults with self-esteem issues using our post-Columbine fear as an excuse to indulge in pow­er trips at stu­dents’ expense. I do under­stand that Columbine was an unthink­able tragedy, and one we should take some rea­son­able pre­cau­tions to pre­vent in the future. If we need met­al detec­tors in schools and we need stu­dents to walk through them five days of the week, then let’s install ’em. Nobody wants to say it these days, but free­dom walks hand in hand with risk. You can’t have absolute secu­ri­ty and the kind of free­dom our found­ing fathers believed in at the same time. Cer­tain­ly, some free­doms have to abridged in pub­lic schools. But the com­mu­ni­ty should be in a con­stant dia­log with schools about just how much free­dom can be with­drawn from stu­dents. And stu­dents should par­tic­i­pate in the dialogue.

I see no point in teach­ing stu­dents about Amer­i­ca’s lead­ing role in glob­al free­dom and civ­il rights when they aren’t wit­ness­ing any of that first­hand. How can we expect the next gen­er­a­tion to grow up eager to fight for free­dom when they haven’t tast­ed any?

Lynn Hamil­ton is the edi­tor of the Tybee News, a com­mu­ni­ty news­pa­per serv­ing coastal Geor­gia, and an occa­sion­al con­trib­u­tor to Alter­net. Con­tact her at tybeenews@earthlink.net.

Cyn is Rick's wife, Katie's Mom, and Esther & Oliver's Mémé. She's also a professional geek, avid reader, fledgling coder, enthusiastic gamer (TTRPGs), occasional singer, and devoted stitcher.
Posts created 4259

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Posts

Begin typing your search term above and press enter to search. Press ESC to cancel.

Back To Top