Online Courses Not for Everyone

It should­n’t be sur­pris­ing to any­one that edu­ca­tion is not a “one size fits all” endeav­or, online or else­where. This bit about learn­ing styles, how­ev­er, did sur­prise me:

“Cor­re­la­tions between learn­ing styles and suc­cess in dis­tance edu­ca­tion have shown to be incon­clu­sive,” Strick­land1Shaw­na L. Strick­land, clin­i­cal assis­tant pro­fes­sor in the Uni­ver­si­ty of Mis­souri School of Health Pro­fes­sions said. “How­ev­er, one com­mon theme reap­pears: the suc­cess­ful traits of a dis­tance learn­er are sim­i­lar to the suc­cess­ful traits of an adult learn­er in tra­di­tion­al edu­ca­tion­al settings.”

The arti­cle claims that there’s “a mere 30 per­cent of dis­tance learn­ers actu­al­ly com­plet­ing their cours­es.” It goes on to men­tion that “Dis­tance learn­ing allows the learn­er to over­come tra­di­tion­al bar­ri­ers to learn­ing such as loca­tion, dis­abil­i­ties, time con­straints and famil­ial oblig­a­tions,” but I’m won­der­ing how much they real­ly paid atten­tion to the fact that those of us who enroll in online class­es are often those who have the most bar­ri­ers to stay­ing in school? I take such cours­es because of phys­i­cal dis­abil­i­ties, but I’ve still had to drop my class­es repeat­ed­ly because of ill­ness. There are still dead­lines, and in fact, some online cours­es are “com­pressed,” mak­ing dead­lines even more important.

Strick­land also men­tions “the lack of insti­tu­tion­al sup­port and iso­la­tion involved in the nature of online cours­es.” I’m not sure what kind of sup­port is miss­ing, com­pared to face-to-face class­es, but maybe that’s because I’ve nev­er sought out any “insti­tu­tion­al sup­port.” Does she mean tutoring?

At one point, though, Strick­land refers to “intro­vert­ed per­son­al­i­ties” and “shy indi­vid­u­als” as (appar­ent­ly) being syn­ony­mous, and not get­ting involved in the typ­i­cal class­room set­ting. That’s a pet peeve of mine. Intro­verts are not nec­es­sar­i­ly shy! We’re self-con­tained, and most of us usu­al­ly put more weight on our own val­u­a­tions than those of oth­ers, so we aren’t as vul­ner­a­ble to peer pres­sure. I miss good class­room dis­cus­sions, as I’ve nev­er seen any online class that has man­aged to pro­voke any­thing close. But then, I did­n’t expe­ri­ence any good dis­cus­sions in face-to-face class­es at DeVry, and very, very few at SPSU. In fact, I heard more than a few of my fel­low stu­dents at SPSU com­plain­ing about non-tra­di­tion­al stu­dents, in par­tic­u­lar, want­i­ng to “talk too much” in class. They clear­ly want­ed less dis­cus­sion, not more!

Quotes from “Researcher Finds Not Every­one Can Suc­cess­ful­ly Learn Through Online Cours­es, Despite Their Pop­u­lar­i­ty” at Med­ical News Today

Cyn is Rick's wife, Katie's Mom, and Esther & Oliver's Mémé. She's also a professional geek, avid reader, fledgling coder, enthusiastic gamer (TTRPGs), occasional singer, and devoted stitcher.
Posts created 4247

10 thoughts on “Online Courses Not for Everyone

  1. Weird — the com­ment form is in Spanish. 

    In my expe­ri­ence, schools just aren’t gen­er­al­ly good at deal­ing with atyp­i­cal stu­dents. Hope­ful­ly this will change with time.

  2. I think it’s actu­al­ly Ital­ian. And I thought I had it all trans­lat­ed. I’ll go back through the templates 🙂

  3. I had­n’t seen that par­tic­u­lar arti­cle, but I have read what has post­ed about the sit­u­a­tion. Home­school­ing has always been a lit­tle more irreg­u­lar in Cal­i­for­nia than in states that have spe­cif­ic guide­lines for us. One of the few advan­tages to Geor­gia is that we DO have a good HSing statute in place, no thanks to the HSLDA and oth­er big organizations.

    When I was mar­ried to Katie’s father, before he took the job in south Geor­gia, he con­sid­ered one in Huntsville. I vetoed it because to home­school in Alaba­ma, you HAVE to work with an “umbrel­la” school — usu­al­ly a reli­gious one. Ick!

    (See any lin­ger­ing Italian?)

  4. Ya know, as over­crowd­ed as so many schools are, you’d think folks would see home­school­ing as a pres­sure release. 

    And the only lin­ger­ing Ital­ian I see now is me, and I’m only half 🙂

  5. Every year, the NEA pub­lish­es a screed against home­school­ing. The big issue is the loss of con­trol of stu­dents who will not be indoc­tri­nat­ed into their ideology.

    Even the government/political types who are in favor of home­school­ing often get freaky about peo­ple who aren’t like them doing it. They cer­tain­ly don’t want to con­sid­er how many lit­tle hea­thens are avoid­ing de fac­to Chris­tiniz­ing in gov­ern­ment schools!

  6. I won­der how many school vouch­er bills would­n’t go to vote if the mon­ey could be applied to home school­ing expenses?

  7. I have tried both dis­tance learn­ing and class­room learn­ing, both have advan­tages and dis­ad­van­tages. Dis­tance learn­ing is good for strong mind­ed indi­vid­u­als who have the dri­ve and deter­mi­na­tion to fol­low the course to the let­ter and make sure they com­mit them­selves to com­plet­ing the tasks with­out any prompt­ing. Many peo­ple need the sup­port and encour­age­ment a class­room atmos­phere can bring, a class­room envi­ron­ment is a good place to brush up on social skills which may have been lost. Dis­tance or remote learn­ing does have some advan­tages over onsite learn­ing and this is time tak­en to get to a course, it also allows a stu­dent to fit in the lessons as suit­ed to their free time. Per­son­al­ly I would rather take class­room lessons and enjoy not only the top­ic but also the social inter­ac­tiv­i­ty between oth­er like-mind­ed students

  8. Yes true dis­tance learn­ing suits dif­fer­ent peo­ple at dif­fer­ent stages in life. It’s only con­vinient based on what one is doing at the time, what com­pro­mis­es and sac­ri­fices one has to make etc. For exam­ple dis­tance learn­ing is def­i­nite­ly con­vinient and appeal­ing to an employ­ee who is offered to learn while they work, espe­cial­ly dur­ing work­ing hours. Thus they don’t have to leave work to rush to a class­room after work at the expense of their fam­i­ly and oth­er per­son­al obligations. 

    When they talk about social iso­la­tion in dis­tance learn­ing, I think this is spe­cial­ly address­ing the young learn­ers, tee­negers and those start­ing col­lege. For this group of peo­ple, dis­tance learn­ing may not be suit­able to them because part of their rea­son for going to col­lege is for the phys­i­cal, social con­nec­tion and inter­ac­tion with oth­ers, to inter­act with peers and build rela­tion­ships. With dis­tance learn­ing, most often one is study­ing alone. Thus this young group of learn­ers may feel iso­lat­ed or miss that social phys­i­cal inter­ac­tion that comes with attend­ing a tra­di­tion­al classroom. 

    A key fac­tor to suc­cess­ful online learn­ing is moti­va­tion. A learn­er needs to be self-dri­ven and an inde­pen­dent thinker who enjoys work­ing alone. Being moti­vat­ed means that one needs to be inter­est­ed in the cours­es and pro­gram, keep in touch with the instruc­tor, class­mates, read­ings etc and see the light at the end of the tun­nel. Unmo­ti­vat­ed learn­ers or those with poor study habits often fall behind in their online courses.

Comments are closed.

Related Posts

Begin typing your search term above and press enter to search. Press ESC to cancel.

Back To Top